GT Writing Task 2 / Essay Sample # 312
You should spend about 40 minutes on this task.
Write about the following topic:
Some people think that success is the best measure of intelligence, while others think that intelligence can be measured in other ways.
What is your opinion on this?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Model Answer 1:
In the realm of human intelligence, the concept of measuring it solely through the lens of success is overly simplistic and fails to capture the multifaceted nature of intellectual abilities. While success in certain domains can be an indicator of intelligence, it is not the sole measure, and there are alternative ways to assess intelligence more effectively.
To begin with, success is a subjective and context-dependent concept. It is often measured by societal standards, which can vary across cultures and time periods. Success in one area, such as business or academics, may not accurately reflect an individual’s overall intellectual abilities. Furthermore, success can be influenced by factors beyond intelligence, such as personal connections, opportunities, and luck. Therefore, relying solely on success as a measure of intelligence may lead to biased and incomplete assessments.
Instead, intelligence can be more effectively measured through a multidimensional approach. One such approach is the theory of multiple intelligences proposed by Howard Gardner, which acknowledges diverse intellectual strengths, including linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and naturalistic bits of intelligence. This framework allows for a broader understanding of intelligence, accommodating individuals with different strengths and talents.
Additionally, cognitive assessments, such as IQ tests, provide a more objective and standardized measure of intelligence. These tests evaluate various cognitive abilities, such as problem-solving, logical reasoning, and pattern recognition. While they have their limitations and should not be the sole determinant of intelligence, they offer a more comprehensive and quantitative assessment compared to measuring intelligence solely through success. Moreover, qualities like creativity, critical thinking, adaptability, and emotional intelligence are essential aspects of intelligence that cannot be accurately captured by measuring success alone.
In conclusion, success is an incomplete measure of intelligence as it is subjective, context-dependent, and influenced by factors beyond intellectual abilities. By adopting a more comprehensive approach to measuring intelligence, we can better appreciate the diverse range of intellectual capabilities and promote a more inclusive and holistic understanding of intelligence.
Model Answer 2:
Some would argue that success is the best yardstick of intelligence, yet others believe that intelligence can be evaluated through other methods. While success is a standard method of measuring intelligence, I believe that various standardized tests prove to be effective ways to assess an individual’s talent.
On the one hand, success is seen as the best indicator of intelligence. This is because brilliant people are better able to overcome all obstacles on their way to success, despite having no academic qualifications or limited financial resources. Steve Jobs, Apple’s famed co-founder, is a case in point. He becomes phenomenally successful, despite dropping out of college. I believe that this is often not the case because hard work and determination play important roles in such success stories.
On the other hand, various standardized tests are devised specifically to evaluate human brilliance. For instance, the commonly used Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS), the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC) and Stanford–Binet IQ tests are all standardized tests designed to assess intelligence. I think these standardized tests are more accurate because they are widely used in various fields, such as education, business, psychology and so on, for their ability to assess and predict performance. For example, SAT (Scholastic Assessment Test) is used to help college authorities decide whether candidates are eligible for special-education programs.
To reiterate, success is regarded by many as the most appropriate way to measure intelligence. But, I think standardized tests are better methods for assessing the intellectual capacity of human beings because they are usually more accurate and applicable to a wide range of people.